This is my post for Alex Cavanaugh’s Insecure Writer’s
Support Group for the month of August. We
are writers helping writers here folks. To
read more posts, click on this link.
One of the rules of good writing tells us to show characters in logical sequences of action.
If you have someone in a room one moment, they can’t
appear on the street in the same scene, unless you use your words to get them there. I learned this a long time ago. Good news, bad news. I know what I’m supposed to do, but my method
is flawed. Last night, in class, I read
pages and received direct, actionable feedback from our teacher. “Stop with the stage direction,” she said.
Once I understood, I met this criticism with relief. I’ve been so busy whirling my characters
around, marching them back, making them look both ways before crossing the
street, I’ve been slowing my action down. I can’t tell you how I’ve searched for other
ways to say, “She turned,” or “she stepped” when I didn’t need to say it at
all.
Here’s are two examples, directly from my work. In paragraph A, you’ll find the
original pokey, bla, bla, bla version.
In paragraph B, a revision.
A) “Spinning around, she glanced toward the
empty doorway to the market. Waiting for two cars to pass, she crossed the street
and headed toward Waban Avenue, where the historical society stood, on the far
side of the library, three doors down from the corner.”
B) “She crossed the street and headed toward
Waban Avenue. The historical society stood
on the far side of the library. Three
doors down from the corner.”
A) “Turning, she ran from the room, ignoring
the greeting offered by a black-haired woman now manning the front desk. Pushing at the heavy door, she vaulted down
the steps oblivious to the stares of a white haired man gripping the wrought
iron railing as he climbed his way up. Crossing the sidewalk, she leaned on the trunk
of a maple tree, holding her pounding temples. Uneven tree bark dug into her back. Fighting to slow her breathing, she examined
the cracks in the sidewalk in front of her.
“Keep to the program,” her therapist advised when she described how
panic threatened to swamp her. “Try not
to give into it.”
B) “Marnie bolted. Vaulting down the steps, she leaned on the
trunk of a maple. Fighting to slow her
breathing, she examined the cracks in the sidewalk. “Keep to the program,” her therapist advised
when she described how panic threatened to swamp her. ‘Try not to give into it.’"
In both cases, I think you'll agree once I eliminated the “move to
the right" detail, things move much faster.
14 comments:
I'm going through this exercise right now. The things I'm working on are so overwritten I can't stand myself.
I'll email you the reasons why.
Now I want to go through my latest manuscript and see if I'm not doing the same.
And you did really well for almost missing the IWSG! This is good stuff.
It looks like that class is reeeeeally helpful to you, because your revisions make a huge difference. Great post! (Helpful, too.)
I can see how the B's read much better than the A's - but I did like 'spinning around, she glanced toward the empty doorway to the market'. I could just imagine it so clearly :)
Suzanne @ Suzannes-Tribe
You did MUCH better with your rewrites. I have some other thoughts which I'll email you.
I'm working on that in my writing too. So glad I stopped by today.
Wow. I think I am guilty of this, too. Very helpful stuff, Liza.
Great advice. I tend to do the opposite and under-describe, so readers get confused about how my characters ended up moving from one place to another! So when I'm revising, I have to add in more words for clarity and slow the pacing down. Having critiques helps! :)
Great advice! I think we all need to learn, and then probably re-learn, to get let the story flow and get out of the way.
Kim Lajevardi
(This Writer's Growing)
I do that, too. It's hard to find the right balance between telling too much and not enough. You don't want your readers saying, huh? How did they get there? But you also don't want them groaning under detail. I like the way you revised :)
YES!!! That's exactly what I do. And I always remember this local film that was in the film festival about twenty years ago - it had people going to - oh I don't know - Graceland I think - and they had a plane scene so you'd know how they got there! Gah! So dopey. Who cares? It had nothing to do with the story and the film-maker had to make an airplane set. Jeez! The first draft is like a teenager coming home from a movie and telling you the whole plot in excruciating detail. It is the story we tell ourselves. We want to know just where everything is! So funny - thanks for the reminder.
As you mention, sometimes slow is good for effect, but when it tempts your reader to skim, no good. I still struggle with this concept--I like the description "stage direction." So many actions are already implied and understood by our reader. Just need to keep reminding myself of that ...
Good job! This is an important lesson to learn. Congrats.
I'm a big offender of this one, too. lol I just feel like, how will they know that they're over there now? lol
Post a Comment