Welcome to IWSG Day. The goal of this blog hop is to share
and encourage. Writers can express doubts and concerns without fear of
appearing foolish or weak. Those who have been through the fire can offer
assistance and guidance. It’s a haven for insecure writers of all
kinds. IWSG is the brainchild of Alex Cavanaugh. Thank
you to October co-hosts, Nancy Gideon, Jennifer Lane, Jacqui Murray, and Natalie Aguirre. To read posts from other
contributors, click here.
October optional question: Ghost stories fit right in during this month. What's your
favorite classic ghostly tale? Tell us about it and why it sends chills up your
spine.
My favorite ghost story isn’t a Halloween story, but it’s a
classic. I’m not much of a scary story kind of girl, so it’s probably good that
my first experience with A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens was a version featuring
Mr. Magoo, the bumbling, vision impaired cartoon character from the 1960’s. How
frightening could a story be with him as the star? By the time I was assigned
to read the actual tale for high school English it was like returning to an old
friend.
But it was the 1984 movie starring George C. Scott that put
A Christmas Carol at the top of my favorite scale. We first watched it back in the
VCR days, and my husband and I liked that adaptation so much we taped it, rewinding
and playing it again every Christmas. There is still a DVD of it stored in a box
labeled “Christmas Movies” at the top of my family room closet.
Scott is chillingly believable as the miserly Scrooge denying Bob Cratchit his piece of coal and returning to his own frigid house for a bowl of broth on Christmas Eve. He assumes it's his imagination when he hears the rattling of chains from the ghost of his late
partner, some kind of dream triggered by a digestive complaint. Once he accepts the visitations are real however, he becomes incrementally more sympathetic as the ghosts
of past, present and future show him what his worship of money has cost him and what more he stands to lose. Scott is marvelous as a newly reformed Scrooge,
jumping up and down on his bed the next morning as he realizes all the good he can do.
So, yes, it’s my favorite take on my favorite ghost story
because the acting is so superb it feels real. Even now, the sound of the screeching whine that accompanies the beckoning finger of the Ghost of Christmas Past gives me the willies. For those of you not of a certain age, picture a dementor from the Harry Potter movies. When the apparition
first arrives, it scares the Dickens out of Scrooge (lol), and no matter how many times I watch it, it does the same
to me.
What is your favorite ghost story? Is there a particular scene that sticks with you?
6 comments:
That's a popular choice today. And that version is really good. So is the one from the 60's.
The dementor from HP scares me too. I still remember the horror I felt when I first saw it😅
Ha! I'm chuckling reading that there's a Mr. Magoo Christmas Carol. Never saw it. And I haven't thought of Mr. Magoo in decades.
OMG I had forgotten about the 1984 version of A Christmas Carol. And as soon as I read your post I remembered a scene with Scott cringing, eyes closed, and crying "Spirit!" So now I need to re-watch the movie for the first time in 40 years.
Hi Liza - I'd go for the very British version of A Christmas Caroll with Alastair Sim as Scrooge, and Michael Hordern as Marley ... or the 1970 one with Albert Finney and Alec Guinness as Marley's ghost. But so well written - we can learn so much from Dickens' works and his way of presenting his stories ... cheers Hilary
The George C Scott version is my favorite, too. :)
Post a Comment